Paul Hassebroek

Writing About Business and Personal Finance

Why Advisor Compensation Matters

How the person providing your investment advice is compensated could have a bigger impact on your financial plan's success than any other factor. Compensation drives the quality of advice and the amount of time an advisor spends working for you. In the investment business, there are three popular model firms utilize to deliver investments or investment advice to their clients.

The first and most common compensation model is the commission model. In this model, the advisor, known as Registered Representatives, are compensated by the investments they recommend. A commission compensated advisor might sell products like life insurance, mutual funds, and annuities.

A second model is called fee-based. These advisors usually have licenses or the CFP(tm) which allow them to give advice for a fee in addition to their Registered Representative licenses. They may call themselves Financial Advisors, Financial Planners, or a number of other titles. These dual licenses advisors are called fee-based because they primarily provide investment advice for a fee, but also utilize annuities, life insurance, and other securities in their practices that pay a commission to the advisor for making a sale.

The third business model is the fee-only business model. Practitioners of this model are licensed as Investment Advisor Representatives of a Registered Investment Advisor (RIA). The term fee-only acknowledges the fact that they are only compensated by the fees their clients pay them. (related: Wall Street Journal: Sometimes Fee-only Isn't What You Think)

Surprisingly, most advisors aren't fee-only and many don't provide advice for a fee at all. For now I will avoid the discussion of why that is and instead focus on why fee-only makes sense:

  1. Avoiding the possibility of a conflict of interest. There may not be any conflict of interest when a advisor sells you a security, but how can an investor know? By not receiving commissions for the investments recommended, a fee-only advisor eliminates the possibility of any pressures from the issuers of investments to recommend a certain security or strategy.

  2. Commissions are paid up front. I'm sure the purchaser of a mutual fund from an advisor believes they will be receiving service and advice after the sale, but what is the advisor's incentive to do so? Fee-only advisors typically charge an hourly rate for a pre-defined amount of work or they charge a fee based on the assets they are managing. The fee-only advisor is then required to continue working for the client to earn their fee as the client can end the relationship at any point.

  3. Incentive for performance. If the fee-only advisor is being compensated as a percentage of assets he or she is managing, then they can earn a larger fee as the account grows. This creates an incentive (in addition to other requirements to do so) for the advisor to provide regular service and advice to the client in an effort to grow the account.

If you haven't picked up on it, I am a believer in fee-only investment advice. So much so, that it is the model I've chosen for my own business. I value the transparency of the RIA model and I think it allows for strong client/advisor relationships. When presented with their financial plan and investment recommendation, clients of a fee-only advisor know that there is no question as to why a recommendation was made. And I think that's critically important when dealing with something as important as your financial future.


View Comments


The Ten Most Expensive Cars Of 2014

There were several high profile collector car sales last year. The ten on this list compiled by Classic Car, totaled $141mm. The nine highest were Ferraris with a Ferrari beating race car by Ford at number 10. Read the rest at Classic Car.…

Read More


Oil Closes Below $50

Oil prices continued to fall today with the WTI contract closing below $50 per barrel, a price not seen in five and a half years. 2015 hasn't started great for the equity markets either as the S&P 500 fell for the fourth day. I'm not crazy enough to predict which direction oil will go, but my family is enjoying the low gas prices while they last.…

Read More


The Tenth Year

I started my business on December 1st, 2005. The past nine years have taught me a lifetime's worth of knowledge as I've been an advisor, counselor, business owner, accountant, and janitor, among other roles. Some time ago, I started planning for my tenth year in business. This included looking critically at all aspects of my business including customer service, investment research and implementation, and marketing and client acquisition. Fred Wilson recently wrote this post about the process entrepreneurs go through to build their businesses. In his post, he describes two paths: the pivot and the Grind. In the start-up world,…

Read More


A Christmas Gift: The Story of New York's Bull

According to the Wall Street Journal, it's already been 25 years since that 18 foot, 3½ ton bronze bull arrived in New York City. As the paper tells the story, guerilla artist Arturo Di Modica snuck it in to the city on a flatbed truck as a Christmas gift to New York City. Di Modica left it in the middle of Broad Street near the New York Stock Exchange. Authorities quickly removed the statue from the street and deposited it a few blocks away in its current location, where it has become a tourist attraction and a mascot for Wall…

Read More


The Future Is Here

NASA just emailed a wrench to the space station. This was the first time that an object has been transmitted from Earth to space for manufacture. Once at the space station, the wrench was printed on a 3D printer for astronaut Barry Wilmore to use for a specific purpose. Barry Wilmore - credit: NASA This wasn't the first object made in space, but it was the first time an object was designed specifically for a task. This is very exciting for the future as 3D printers will become more common and the materials they can print more durable. Future in-field…

Read More


Iowa Farmland Values Drop Year Over Year

Farmland dropped in value per acre in 2014 versus the previous year. Since 1941, Iowa State University in Ames, IA has surveyed land values in each of Iowa's 99 counties. This year, the responsibility for the survey was transferred to the Center for Agricultural and Rural Development. The survey results showed that the state of Iowa average value of farmland fell by $773/acre or 8.9% from last year's record high value. The average acre of Iowa farmland in 2014 is $7,943/acre, but varies from county to county. source image credit: wikicommons…

Read More


CFP Designation Gains Traction With Advisors

The CFP designation has been grew in acceptance by advisors in 2013. Nearly half of advisors surveyed by wealthmanagement.com said they either have or are pursuing the designation. Another 14% of advisors said they have or are pursing the CFA, up from 11 percent in 2013. I found this interesting as I've been looking at the CFP for my own financial planning business. ...the designation is gaining favor amount RIA firms, as possible sign that the organization's advertising campaign is working. wealthmanagement.com source: wealthmanagement.com…

Read More


Don't Underestimate Yourself

Read More


banksy On The New iPhone

pic.twitter.com/CL2W0rUNRc— banksy (@thereaIbanksy) September 12, 2014…

Read More


Happy Blog Birthday!

Today marks the first anniversary of this blog. Over this past year, I've learned what sort of posts people want to read and how difficult it is to really write on a regular basis. One big highlight for the year, was when the blog was selected by Brightscope as one of the top 100 financial advisor blogs to read. I received a lot of positive feedback from that and it was very encouraging. The main purpose of this blog is to become a better writer. Additionally, I had hoped it would stimulate discussions around investing and personal finance and help…

Read More


Quote

“Anyone who isn't embarrassed of who they were last year probably isn't learning enough.” ~ Alain de Botton…

Read More